MemberPass vs MyMembers
Two Telegram subscription bots — different gateway depth, different fee shapes
MyMembers and MemberPass solve the same problem — paid Telegram access — and both have a path with no monthly platform fee. MyMembers's pitch is simple: 5% commission, £0 platform cost, 3-minute setup, Stripe-only. MemberPass goes deeper: 9 payment gateways including Telegram Stars, regional providers, and crypto, plus a public REST API, official Zapier and n8n integrations, and an MCP server. Pick MyMembers if Stripe is enough and a flat 5% fits your numbers. Pick MemberPass if you want gateway depth, integrations, or a lower fee at scale.
Comparación de funciones
| Función | MemberPass | MyMembers |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Telegram subscription communities | Telegram subscription bot |
| Telegram Stars | Native support | Not listed |
| Pasarelas de pago | 9 gateways | Stripe only |
| Regional Gateways | Razorpay (India), Paystack (Africa), CeyPay (Sri Lanka) | Not available |
| Crypto Support | BTC, ETH, USDT, USDC via CoinPayments + CeyPay | Not available |
| Pricing Model | $0 Free + 10%, $39 Starter + 3%, $89 Growth + 1% | £0 platform fee + 5% commission, no monthly tier |
| Tiered Memberships | Multi-resource per plan | Tiered memberships available |
| Trial Periods | Plan-level and cardless trials | Free trials and discounted first-month offers |
| Códigos de acceso | Single-use, batch, gift codes — included on all plans | Not listed |
| REST API / Webhooks | 18 resources, 71 events — fully public | Not advertised |
| Zapier / n8n / MCP | Official Zapier app, n8n node, 42-tool MCP server | Not listed |
| Multi-Project Isolation | Each project isolated — separate plans, subscribers, payments, teams | Multi-channel listed; multi-project isolation between separate businesses not advertised |
| Team RBAC | 35 fine-grained permissions on Growth (community manager, billing admin, support) | Not advertised |
| Activity Log | Full audit trail — every action logged with actor and timestamp | Not advertised |
Lo que MyMembers hace bien
- A simple flat 5% commission with no monthly fee is easy to model when Stripe is your only payment route.
- MyMembers's site claims £160/month savings versus competitors charging 15% + £110 in monthly platform costs — credible at low-to-mid revenue.
- MyMembers advertises a 3-minute setup with no coding — a strong onboarding experience for non-technical creators.
- Money goes directly to your Stripe account with each subscription — no payout schedule or holding period.
- Free trials and discounted first-month offers come built in, making conversion funnels straightforward to set up.
Creemos en comparaciones honestas. Si MyMembers es adecuado para ti, te lo diremos.
Precios
- Free$0/mo10% per transaction— 3 projects
- Starter$39/mo3% per transaction— Unlimited projects
- Growth$89/mo1% per transaction— Unlimited + Teams
- Nivel gratuito£0/mo5% commission (Stripe processing on top)— Stripe-only, no monthly tier — site does not specify if 5% includes Stripe fees
Donde MemberPass gana
Telegram Stars — MyMembers does not list support
Telegram Stars lets subscribers pay inside Telegram without a card or external checkout. MyMembers's site doesn't list Stars support. MemberPass supports Stars natively.
9 payment gateways vs Stripe only
MemberPass supports Stripe, PayPal, Razorpay, Paystack, Skrill, CoinPayments, CeyPay, and Telegram Stars. MyMembers is Stripe-only. If your audience can't pay through Stripe, MyMembers cannot serve them.
Regional gateways for non-UK/EU audiences
Razorpay covers India and 85+ currencies. Paystack covers Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, Kenya, and more. CeyPay covers Sri Lanka. If your audience is in these markets, MemberPass is the only choice that actually works for them.
Crypto checkout for crypto-native audiences
CoinPayments and CeyPay let your subscribers pay with BTC, ETH, USDT, USDC, and stablecoins across multiple chains. MyMembers has no crypto support.
Access codes for offline and gift subscriptions
Generate single-use or batch access codes subscribers redeem without a card — useful for gifting, in-person sales, and affiliate promos. MyMembers's site doesn't list access codes.
Public REST API, 71 webhook events, Zapier, n8n, MCP
MemberPass has a documented public REST API, 71 webhook events, an official Zapier app, an n8n community node, and an MCP server with 42 tools. MyMembers doesn't advertise any of these.
Lower fee at scale
MyMembers charges a flat 5% commission. MemberPass Starter ($39/mo) charges 3%, and Growth ($89/mo) charges 1%. Above roughly $2,000–$3,000 in monthly revenue, MemberPass's tiered pricing comes out ahead.
Multi-project isolation, team RBAC, and audit trail
Agencies running paid communities for multiple clients need project-level isolation between separate businesses, role-based team access, and an audit log. MemberPass Growth includes 35 fine-grained permissions, project-level isolation between clients, and a full activity log with actor and timestamp. MyMembers advertises multi-channel support but doesn't list multi-project isolation, role-based team access, or an activity log.
Elige MemberPass si tú...
- Creators outside US/UK/EU needing Razorpay, Paystack, or CeyPay
- Communities whose audience pays in crypto
- Anyone wanting to accept Telegram Stars
- Builders who want Zapier, n8n, REST API, or MCP
- High-revenue creators where Growth's 1% beats a flat 5% commission
- Creators who need access codes for offline or gift subscriptions
- Agencies managing multiple client communities needing project isolation, team RBAC, and an audit trail
Quédate con MyMembers si tú...
- Creators with low revenue, Stripe-only audiences, and no need for API or integrations — MyMembers's flat 5% with no monthly fee fits that case well.
- Anyone who wants the absolute fastest non-technical setup with no plan tier decisions.
Preguntas frecuentes
¿Listo para probar MemberPass?
Empieza gratis con 3 proyectos. Sin cuota mensual hasta que decidas actualizar.
Configura gratis en 30 minutos