Tüm Karşılaştırmalar
Platform Karşılaştırması

MemberPass vs TGMembership

Two Telegram-native subscription platforms compared honestly

TGMembership and MemberPass both do the same core job: automate paid access to private Telegram channels and groups. Both support Telegram Stars, both have webhook systems, API access, and solid payment gateway coverage. Where they differ is in automation depth, team structure, and the tools they connect to — Zapier, n8n, and AI-agent workflows.

30 Dakikada Ücretsiz Kurulum

Özellik Karşılaştırması

Özellik MemberPass TGMembership
Admin Interface Full web dashboard for projects, subscribers, plans, payments, access codes, teams Primitive bot-driven interface — most management happens inside Telegram chats with the bot
Platform Stack Modern Laravel + Livewire stack, CDN-backed, fast page loads, actively extended Long-running legacy platform — dated product design and aging infrastructure
Telegram Yıldızları Native support Destekleniyor
Team RBAC 35 fine-grained permissions + custom roles (Growth plan) Team collaboration with different access levels — no granular role definitions
Zapier Integration Official Zapier app Not available
n8n Integration Official n8n community node Not available
MCP Sunucusu 42 tools for AI-agent control Not available
API Documentation 18 resource types — fully public docs Public API docs — resource scope not as comprehensive
Crypto Coverage Bitcoin, ETH, USDT, USDC via CoinPayments + CeyPay 200+ cryptocurrencies via NowPayments and BinancePay
Additional Gateways Stripe, PayPal, Razorpay, Paystack, Skrill, CeyPay Stripe, PayPal, Paddle, Razorpay, Paystack, Revolut, Binance Pay, NowPayments
Erişim Kodları Included — no add-on fee Included
Pricing Model USD flat monthly + % transaction fee EUR sliding scale — rate drops as revenue grows (no monthly fee)
Ücretsiz Katman $0/mo, 3 projects, 10% fee €0 platform fee on first €85 of revenue per billing cycle

TGMembership'in İyi Yaptığı Şeyler

  • TGMembership supports 200+ cryptocurrencies via NowPayments and BinancePay — broader crypto coverage than MemberPass. If your community deals in less common coins, TGMembership covers more of them.
  • TGMembership supports Telegram Stars natively — subscribers can pay directly inside Telegram without a card or external checkout.
  • Paddle and Revolut are available as payment gateways — both unavailable in MemberPass.
  • Built-in eGoods module for selling digital products (documents, photos, videos, files) alongside subscriptions — no separate tool needed. Plus a built-in affiliate module.
  • Sliding-scale pricing means the platform fee drops automatically as your revenue grows — no need to manually upgrade a plan to get a lower rate.

Dürüst karşılaştırmalara inanıyoruz. TGMembership sizin için uygunsa, bunu belirtiriz.

Fiyatlandırma

MemberPass
  • Free$0/mo10% per transaction— 3 projects
  • Starter$39/mo3% per transaction— Unlimited projects
  • Growth$89/mo1% per transaction— Unlimited + Teams
TGMembership
  • Free tier€00% on first €85 of revenue per billing cycle— No monthly fee ever
  • Up to €200/mo€0/mo9% platform fee— After free tier
  • Up to €800/mo€0/mo3–6% platform fee— Rate drops as revenue grows
  • Up to €5,000/mo€0/mo1–2% platform fee— Enterprise available at €20k+

MemberPass'in Kazandığı Noktalar

Professional web dashboard

MemberPass ships with a full web dashboard for managing projects, subscribers, plans, payments, access codes, and team members. TGMembership relies on a basic, primitive bot-driven interface — most management happens inside Telegram chats with the bot, not a proper admin UI.

Modern stack — fast and extensible

TGMembership has been around for years and shows it: dated product design, aging infrastructure, and a feature set that grew by accretion. MemberPass is built on a current Laravel + Livewire stack, deployed behind a CDN, with snappy page loads, a clean web UI, and an extension surface (REST API, webhooks, Zapier, n8n, MCP) designed for builders who want to plug in.

Formal team RBAC with 35 permissions

TGMembership's team feature allows adding staff with different access levels, but without granular role definitions. MemberPass Growth includes 35 fine-grained permissions with custom roles: separate access for community managers, billing admins, and support staff.

Official Zapier and n8n integrations

MemberPass has an official Zapier app and n8n community node. Connect to thousands of tools without code — CRMs, email platforms, analytics, webhooks. TGMembership has no official Zapier or n8n integration.

MCP server for AI-native workflows

MemberPass ships a Model Context Protocol server with 42 tools. AI assistants can query subscriber data, manage access, and run reports. No equivalent exists in TGMembership.

USD pricing — predictable costs

TGMembership prices in EUR. If you earn in USD, your platform cost fluctuates with exchange rates. MemberPass prices everything in USD with a fixed monthly fee, so your costs are predictable.

Fixed monthly cost at scale

TGMembership's sliding scale means you never pay a monthly subscription, but you always pay a percentage. MemberPass Growth at $89/mo + 1% is a known, capped cost. At $5,000/month revenue: TGMembership charges ~€50 (1%) vs MemberPass Growth's $139 total — the gap is narrow, but MemberPass's fixed fee is easier to budget.

Eğer şunlardan biriyseniz MemberPass'i seçin…

  • Creators who want a full web admin dashboard instead of managing everything inside Telegram bot chats
  • Anyone who values a modern, fast product on a current stack over a long-running legacy platform
  • Agencies and teams needing formal role-based access control with separate permissions per user
  • Builders using Zapier, n8n, or AI agents (MCP) in their workflow
  • USD-earning creators who prefer predictable fixed monthly costs
  • Creators who want a fully public, well-documented REST API with 18 resource types

Eğer şunlardan biriyseniz TGMembership ile devam edin…

  • Creators who need broad cryptocurrency coverage beyond Bitcoin/ETH/USDT — TGMembership's 200+ coin support via NowPayments and BinancePay is wider.
  • Creators who want Paddle or Revolut as a payment gateway — neither is available in MemberPass.
  • Anyone who wants a built-in eGoods module (digital product delivery) alongside community subscriptions, without paying for a separate tool.
  • Creators who prefer a no-monthly-fee model where the platform rate automatically decreases as their revenue grows.

Sıkça Sorulan Sorular

Yes — TGMembership supports Telegram Stars natively. Both MemberPass and TGMembership support Stars payments. The key differences between the platforms are in automation integrations (Zapier, n8n, MCP), team RBAC, and pricing structure.
Both platforms have webhook systems with HMAC signature verification. MemberPass fires 71 documented webhook events covering every subscription lifecycle state, with public documentation for each event payload.
No. TGMembership has no official Zapier app or n8n node. MemberPass has both, plus an MCP server for AI-agent integration.
TGMembership has broader crypto coverage — 200+ cryptocurrencies via NowPayments and BinancePay. MemberPass supports Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, USDT, and USDC via CoinPayments, plus stablecoins via CeyPay. If you need less common coins, TGMembership covers more. For the major coins, both work.
TGMembership charges no monthly subscription — instead, a sliding platform fee on revenue: 9% under €200/month, dropping to 1% over €5,000/month. The first €85 of revenue per billing cycle is free. MemberPass charges a fixed monthly fee ($39 or $89) plus a flat transaction rate (3% or 1%). TGMembership's model is lower cost at low revenue; MemberPass's flat fee is more predictable at higher volumes.

MemberPass'i Denemeye Hazır mısınız?

3 projeyle ücretsiz başlayın. Yükseltmeye hazır olana kadar aylık ücret yok.

30 Dakikada Ücretsiz Kurulum
Yol Haritalarımız