Tüm Karşılaştırmalar
Platform Karşılaştırması

MemberPass vs Whop

Telegram-native subscription platform vs. multi-product marketplace

Whop is a marketplace built for creators who sell multiple things: Discord communities, courses, digital downloads, software subscriptions. If that's you, Whop's built-in audience of 2 million weekly visitors is a real advantage. MemberPass does one thing — paid Telegram communities — and it does it natively, with payment gateways, billing cycles, and access control built specifically for how Telegram works.

30 Dakikada Ücretsiz Kurulum

Özellik Karşılaştırması

Özellik MemberPass Whop
Primary Focus Telegram subscription communities Multi-platform marketplace (Discord, courses, downloads)
Telegram Yıldızları Native support — subscribers pay inside Telegram Not supported
Regional Gateways Razorpay (India), Paystack (Africa), CeyPay (Sri Lanka) Primarily US, UK, EU payment methods
Fund Settlement Direct to your account — $0 payout fee Held by Whop — payout fees up to $23 per withdrawal
Erişim Kodları Offline and gift subscriptions — included Not available
Free Plan $0/mo, 3 projects, 10% fee No $0/mo plan — commission from first sale
MCP Sunucusu 42 tools for AI-agent control Not available
Built-in Discovery Bring your own audience via portal link 2M+ weekly marketplace visitors

Whop'in İyi Yaptığı Şeyler

  • Whop has a built-in marketplace — creators get discovered by buyers browsing the platform, which can drive organic signups without any paid marketing.
  • Better for mixed product lines: if you sell courses, digital downloads, Discord communities, and software access together, Whop manages all of it in one dashboard.
  • Whop supports 100+ payment methods across 135+ currencies and has a strong developer API with the Standard Webhooks spec.

Dürüst karşılaştırmalara inanıyoruz. Whop sizin için uygunsa, bunu belirtiriz.

Fiyatlandırma

MemberPass
  • Free$0/mo10% per transaction— 3 projects
  • Starter$39/mo3% per transaction— Unlimited projects
  • Growth$89/mo1% per transaction— Unlimited + Teams
Whop
  • WhopNo monthly fee~3% platform commission + 2.7%+$0.30 processing— Plus payout fees on every withdrawal

MemberPass'in Kazandığı Noktalar

Telegram Stars — Whop has no integration

Telegram Stars is Telegram's native payment method. Subscribers pay directly inside the app without a card or external checkout. Whop has no Stars integration. MemberPass supports Stars natively.

Regional gateways Whop doesn't offer

Razorpay covers India and 85+ currencies. Paystack covers Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, Kenya, and more. CeyPay covers Sri Lanka. If a meaningful portion of your audience is in these markets, MemberPass is the only option that actually works for them.

Your money goes directly to you — no payout fees

MemberPass never touches your revenue. Payments settle directly to your Stripe account, PayPal, or crypto wallet. Whop holds your earnings and charges $2.50 for next-day ACH, 4%+$1 for instant transfers, or $23 for bank wires.

Access codes for offline and gift subscriptions

Generate bulk access codes subscribers redeem without a card — useful for gifting memberships, in-person sales, or markets where card payments are uncommon. Whop has no equivalent.

MCP server for AI-native workflows

MemberPass ships a Model Context Protocol server with 42 tools. Your AI assistant can query subscriber data, check analytics, and manage access programmatically. No other Telegram monetization platform offers this.

Free plan with real utility

3 projects, $0/month, 10% transaction fee. You can run a real paid Telegram community before spending anything. Whop charges a commission from your first sale.

Eğer şunlardan biriyseniz MemberPass'i seçin…

  • Telegram-first creators who want native bot automation for invites, renewals, and removals
  • Creators outside the US/EU who need Razorpay, Paystack, or CeyPay
  • Communities that want to accept Telegram Stars payments
  • Anyone who wants revenue to settle directly with zero payout fees
  • Builders who want MCP server, Zapier, n8n, or REST API integration
  • Creators who want to start free and upgrade as revenue grows

Eğer şunlardan biriyseniz Whop ile devam edin…

  • Creators with mixed product lines — courses, Discord communities, digital downloads, and software — who want a single marketplace to manage all of it.
  • Creators who benefit from Whop's organic marketplace traffic. If buyers browse Whop to find new communities, that discovery advantage is real.

Sıkça Sorulan Sorular

Yes. You can run both platforms during a transition. Subscribers move to MemberPass when they renew and join through the new portal link. There's no bulk import tool, but the overlap period keeps active members from losing access.
MemberPass is Telegram-only today. Slack, Discord, and Viber expansions are on the public roadmap but not currently available. If Discord is your primary platform right now, Whop or a Discord-native tool is the better choice.
MemberPass never holds your revenue — payments go directly to your Stripe account, PayPal, or crypto wallet. Whop holds your earnings and charges fees to withdraw: $2.50 for next-day ACH, 4%+$1 for instant transfers. Over time, those payout fees add up.
The bot automatically removes them from the Telegram channel or group when their subscription expires. No manual action needed. Grace periods and retry logic for failed payments are configurable.
No. MemberPass has no discovery marketplace. You bring your audience through your portal link — shared in your Telegram bio, social profiles, email list, or wherever your audience already is.

MemberPass'i Denemeye Hazır mısınız?

3 projeyle ücretsiz başlayın. Yükseltmeye hazır olana kadar aylık ücret yok.

30 Dakikada Ücretsiz Kurulum
Yol Haritalarımız